Site Map
:: Bitwise Courses ::
Bitwise Dusty Archives



ruby in steel

learn aikido in north devon

Learn Aikido in North Devon


Section :: Rants and Raves

- Format For Printing...

Wikipedia Censorship Removed (kind of)

But what else is censored in Britain...?
Wednesday 10 December 2008.

I note that the British Internet censors, the Internet Watch Foundation, have reversed their decision to block access to a Wikipedia article as reported here on the blog a couple of days ago.

Initially they banned a page about an album by heavy metal band, The Scorpions, on the basis that an album cover that was produced back in the ‘70s was a "potentially illegal child sexual abuse image".

Following much adverse publicity relating to this decision, the Foundation has now decided to unblock access to Wikipedia on the grounds that "in light of the length of time the image has existed and its wide availability, the decision has been taken to remove this webpage from our list."

This strikes me as a feeble and cowardly decision. If they sincerely believe that the image represents “potentially illegal child sexual abuse”, in what way does its age and availability alter that fact? If these are sufficient criteria, they will no doubt welcome all widely available images of child sexual abuse as long as they are not new.

Just as worrying is the fact that this body can make decisions that block the access of UK internet users to pages which the IWF in its arrogance, thinks are unfit for us to see. The arbitrary nature of its decisions is well illustrated by the initial decision to block a Wikipedia article and the subsequent decision to unblock it when people found out it was blocked in the first place.

What I’d like to know is: what other sites are being blocked to UK internet users? In Britain at the moment two phrases are regularly used to justify all manner of restrictions of freedom. These are ‘terrorism’ and ‘child sexual abuse’. The logic seems to be that no sane person would wish to encourage either activity and we should, therefore, be pleased to support any measures to prevent them. The case of the Wikipedia page highlights the risks we take in permitting censorship bodies to curtail our freedom. I’m sure their motives are good. But their methods and their judgment are questionable.

Curiously, the Foundation has concluded that the Scorpions album cover will not be deemed to be illegal if it is hosted outside the UK. But it may be so deemed if hosted inside the UK:

Any further reported instances of this image which are hosted abroad, will not be added to the list. Any further reported instances of this image which are hosted in the UK will be assessed in line with IWF procedures.



AddThis Social Bookmark Button



generic claritin http://www.redligare.org/spip.php?buy=411318 antibiotics cephalexin xopenex hfa free in mayami baclofen versus zanaflex information about allegra seizures singulair 10 merck pharmaceuticals cymbalta depakote hf in united states muscle relaxer skelaxin information atarax mental status evista 60mg fosamax medical study info about methotrexate solubility pristiq motivation http://www.redligare.org/spip.php?buy=856925 otc zyrtec substitute in uk sore throat amoxicillin cephalexin renal failure herpes bladder valtrex in uk http://www.redligare.org/spip.php?buy=19751 zyprexa quick dissolve http://www.redligare.org/spip.php?buy=933217 about periactin zyrtec commercial lexapro ginko biloba depakote for fibromyalgia belching lexapro premarin price comparisons http://www.redligare.org/spip.php?buy=427568 keppra complaint norvasc swelling aricept generic for extra rogaine strength in new york more clonidine hlc clonidine stability long-term http://www.redligare.org/spip.php?buy=320005 phimosis betnovate lexapro equivolent plavix nutrition http://www.redligare.org/spip.php?buy=597906 biaxin supplier singulair suicide paxil pill erythromycin for alzheimers anafranil memory allegra products flexeril roono levaquin levofloxacin in canada avodart diarrhea concentrated tylenol in mexico fml outdoors topamax dryness tyrosine with paxil kinetics allopurinol exelon 401k zyprexa fast bloodstream http://www.redligare.org/spip.php?buy=728185 precose pears http://www.redligare.org/spip.php?buy=29256 geniric for nexium info about xalatan 0.005